Tradition in the 21st Century: Navigating the Southeast Asian Female Experience
By: Joyce Ng
The Vietnamese film Sweet, Salty, directed by Duong Dieu Linh, is a story of how a woman attempts to negotiate between a tradition that is deeply rooted in Southeast Asian culture and more contemporary views of womanhood. In a period where women are in that liminal space between the two, it is important to tell stories that specific to particular female experiences.
From the first shot we see the main character – beautifully framed with
foliage – embodying a sense of serenity; she’s making time for herself. But
she soon falls when attempting to do a particularly difficult yoga pose. We
panic for a second because she is obscenely pregnant, but she seems fine.
And then it gets worse, she starts crying.
Her inability to do that because she is pregnant reminds her of her place as a mother. The things that she is unable to do physically, and emotionally, due to these constraints. She cries, lying down on the floor at her predicament.
Throughout the short, we see the protagonist constantly reminded of her responsibilities as the centre of the family unit. And she tries to reconcile this with being her own independent person. These limitations are illustrated by the mise-en-scene of the film.
There is a scene in which she is dancing with her friends in her house.
Though the place is lit differently, it is still a space where her
responsibilities are apparent, but for a second, she dismisses them. The
coloured and dancing lights change the mood of the house and she is having
fun with her friends. This is however disrupted by the entrance of her
supposed son-in-law who has come to pick his son up. When he leaves, the
mood has changed and even though they attempt to have fun again, they are
unable to do so because he has taken the microphone. A man has intruded into
their space and because of his actions; he takes away their ability to be
carefree. His presence also reminds her of her position as a mother to him,
and a grandmother to his son. And it is right after that that the party ends
and everyone goes home, leaving her at the door, framed and bounded by her
home which representative of her role as a woman.
Interestingly enough, the short Sweet, Salty is a film about women and a story about men. Throughout the short, not once do we see her husband, but his presence is undeniably domineering in all aspects of her life. The women in the film are constantly talking about him, their conversations surround him and the actions that he has done and hence the consequences that they are left to deal with drive their actions.
We see the protagonist constantly framed within a frame, in that not only is she framed by the film, she is also framed by the mise-en-scene within it. This occurs whenever she is in the presence of people that remind her of the space she inhabits as a woman. She needs to use the bathroom, a necessary human function, and yet she cannot even do that in peace, as the small space is soon filled with her two daughters and her grandson. The framing of the toilet can be seen as the limitations placed onto her by her role as a mother and a grandmother. She is overwhelmed by the central position she occupies and we see her physically remove herself from the frame.
Even when she leaves the overcrowded toilet, she is next framed by the
kitchen wall, which puts her constantly in the frame with her daughters – a
reminder of the boundaries that she has to function under. It is no
coincidence that in these particular scenes, the conversation revolves
around becoming a mother and the consequences of his infidelity.
We also see the protagonist going to a facial, and even dressing up to face her husband’s mistress. While one can say that this is a form of empowerment, it comes from the need to be beautiful in order to win over a man. This is a constant struggle many women deal with over the entirety of their lives, the dichotomy between wanting to feel beautiful through empowerment and ‘doing things from themselves’. However, at the end of the day, they want the attention of men, and perhaps in that, they feel empowered. But at the same time, if their form of validation comes from men, can it truly be empowerment? The focus on beauty, in spite of its implications, is telling of how complicated the structure of the life a woman is in the 21st Century, paerticularly as they attempt to reconcile both feminism and tradition.
In Asian societies, tradition is still at the forefront of our psyches, and attempts to reconcile that with more contemporary attitudes can result in a dissonance. The main character is troubled and angry for a lot of the film, and she has every right to be. But at the end of the film, when her husband is so close, we see her moved to tears and the comfort and happiness that he brings. Perhaps, in her mind, she has somehow won over the heart of her husband by having a boy.
In this sense, we see the contrast between her character throughout the film
and in the last scene and comment on how men are her source of pain, as seen
in her husband’s betrayal, and the source of her happiness, as seen in her
euphoria at the end and the fact that it was brought by her having a son.
Furthermore, the final scene and the first scene are parallels. In one, she
cries because of her sadness, and another, out of happiness. This represents
the endless cycle of struggle that women must face for their entire lives
regarding their place in society, in a family unit, and how that translates
into the person they are and the actions they perform.
– Joyce Ng